Wednesday, October 30, 2019

Student Researcher: How to acquire valid information


Most of my young students are aware that Google and Alexa are sources of information.

However, one day when we were getting ready for recess, a small group of students decided they would meet in the playground to play family.  


"I'll be the mommy!"  
"I'll be the baby!"  
"I'll be the pony!"  
One student who wanted to join in asked quietly, "Who can I be?" 

They paused. All of the positions for this game appeared to be taken. How could they include this new friend?  
Suddenly, a student's face lite up. 
"I know!  Let's ask Alexa who (the child's name) can be!"  

Do my students really believe that Alexa could... or worse, should... answer all their questions?


SOURCES

VARIETY: 

Students should understand that information comes from a variety of sources (not just Alexa!).  Experts, books, television, videos, audiotapes and, most commonly, computer search engines, are all ways we can find information about a subject they are interested in.

IS THE SOURCE VALID?

As educators it is important that we help our young students identify if the source they are using is: 

  1. best one for finding the answer to the question they are asking
  2. a valid source of information 

Some examples of questions I have started asking my students are: 
  • Who told you? How does he/she know? Is he/she an expert? What is an expert? 
  • Did you read it in a book?  Was the book fiction or non-fiction? (this is a really important lesson in preschool)
  • Did you see it on youtube/TV/internet?  Was it an educational show?  Who showed you the program?  Was it a parent, teacher or responsible adult?
The internet is an amazing source of information, but it is also important to realize that not all information on the internet is valid.  


 Website Domain Names  

My PreK students are not doing their own research on the web yet, but the following information is important for older students.
  • .com - a commercial or for-profit organization
  • .org - a nonprofit organization designation (that anyone can apply for)
  • .net - a government agency
  • .K12 - a school 
**An important note is that anything with a tilde (~) within a URL, or that contains a person's name means the site is from a personal website.**


Search Engines

  • Educators can use this tool to identify sites that they know are valid and then let their students search the web within the Custom Google Search Engine they create.  
  • Factmonster.com, kids.nationalgeographic.com, animalplanet.com, learninglab.si.edu (Smithsonian Learning Lab) and Brainpop.com are examples of websites I have added to my Custom Google Search Engines that are useful for young students.
  • My daughter's school has a subscription to this site and students can use it as a source for their research.  I did a quick search on sea turtles and a wealth of information appeared.  You can have a free 7 day trial, but after that, your school would likely purchase a membership. (Service is $1.44/week or $74.95/year)


Green Cavendish Square https://www.cavendishsquaredigital.com/  
  • Her school uses this site to research history.  It also requires a membership fee. There is a 30 trial period and then they will give a quote to continue service.





Google Scholar https://scholar.google.com/schhp?hl=en


  • This is a site for I've used for my own research.  As the title suggests, this site includes scholarly literature.
Just found this today (11/2) and must add!
Search Engines for Kids List: http://ivyjoy.com/rayne/kidssearch.html
I have not used all these sites yet, but this blog offers a TON of information.

No comments:

Post a Comment